Blog for Week 10: Interview
Social media continues to charge forward every day as a
significant pastime for people, especially adolescents. With it, kids can communicate
with friends, indulge in their passions and interests, and be introduced to old
and new experiences. As brought out by Bronwyn Williams, “Online media
technologies have allowed students to construct new performances of identity
and yet also reinforce existing social identities from their face-to-face
relationships” (Williams, 2013, pg. 300). I decided to interview my 14-year-old
twin nieces (we will call them “A” and “B”), as they both just recently got
Instagram accounts and also listen to music through the Apple Music platform. I
wanted to see how much their social media has impacted their lives so far.
First, I asked them how much time they spend on Instagram
per day. They told me about 3 hours. When asked what kind of posts they like to
see, B said “I like makeup [tutorials], and funny videos and stuff,” while A
agreed and added “guitar stuff too.” This spoke to her aspirations to learn
guitar; the twins have their own band with a few friends. B plays bass. Their
parents try to monitor how much time they spend on the site. A told me they “say
it’s time to get off, maybe go on a walk or read a book or something.” I agree
with this kind of intervention; kids need time away from the computer regularly.
As to the advantages of Instagram, both girls say they
prefer to observe content on Instagram rather than make it. B tells me “I like
seeing other people’s posts… I don’t really post much.” She continues, “it’s
entertaining.” I asked them when they do post something, do they get upset when
they don’t get “likes.” B said “obviously you want likes,” although both agreed
that they “don’t really care.” When asked about the dangers, both girls agreed
that there are “a lot,” although they admit they have only heard stories about
them on the news rather than having encountered them personally. A tells me “that’s
why dad wants us to keep our account private,” while B adds “there’s a lot of
creeps out there!”
As suggested earlier, music is a substantial interest for
the twins as well. Ocana-Fernandez and Reyes-Lopez point out that—even from
an early age—kids’ “‘favourite songs’ are part of a common language through
which they recognise, find, censor and accept themselves and each other, both
individually and collectively” (Ocana-Fernandez & Reyes-Lopez, 2019). When
listening to music, both girls use the social media platform Apple Music. B comments
on the convenience of the site: “let’s say I don’t have the album, I just
listen to it on my phone.” However, both girls’ “favorite way” to listen to
music is by listening to “full albums” on vinyl records, having been introduced
to the practice by their older brother. They tell me they like the retro feel
of records, and they have amassed quite an impressive collection of albums so
far. A tells me “it’s cooler.” In addition, I find that their musical tastes
are impressively diverse for 14-year-olds. B lists some of her favorite artists
being “Billie Eilish, Nirvana and Taylor Swift.” A agrees with these artists,
and adds that she likes “some Pink Floyd.” This again speaks to their access to
social media and the internet to introduce musical variety, yet they may also
be influenced heavily by their father and older siblings, who are avid music
fans as well.
Finally, I asked them how they would feel if their parents
took away their social media. B says “I’d feel a little annoyed” but not “heartbroken.”
She adds, “I’d get over it” and “move on.” A adds that “sometimes when I take a
little break” from social media, “I do a lot more, like I have a more
productive day.” This attitude really surprised me. With how many teenagers are
obsessed with Instagram and other platforms, these were some refreshing
responses. I feel parents should make sure their kids have a healthy balance.
Through this interview, I learned quite a bit more about my
nieces and their interests. They are quickly growing up and becoming their own
people who make me proud, and this was a great way to pick their brains. I feel
like connecting with children like this is a terrific way to gain insight into
their passions and try to relate, by tailoring curriculum or just showing you
care about them.
References:
Lankshear & Knobel. (2013). A New Literacies Reader:
Educational Perspectives. Peter Lang Publishing, Inc: New York.
Ocaña-Fernández, Almudena; Reyes-López, Mª Luisa.
(2019) ‘My favorite song’: understanding a music learning ecology of children
from interaction among media, family and school contexts. British
Journal of Music Education; Cambridge. Vol. 36, Iss. 2, (Jul
2019): 113-123. DOI:10.1017/S0265051719000081
Hi Joe,
ReplyDeleteGreat interview - I especially enjoyed your niece's response regarding that she would have a more productive day if she wasn't able to use technology. Today, we had a group of senior girls get back from a four day back pack trip in the Adirondacks. For the entirety of the trip these girls had no cellphone service and therefor no contact with the outside world. One of the girls today mentioned to me that she had barely touched Instagram since she had gotten back - as she didn't feel the need after four days away. These girls are always on social media in school, so what a realization for her to make! (and quite similar to your niece's response too).
Technology is a great tool, but its important we all take a step back from it from time to time to help clear our minds. "Disconnect to reconnect".
Thanks for your post,
Sam